Loading…
Judged on temperament and exercise needs, not on looks.
De Pet Valley · · 4 min read
If a dog that has always been patient suddenly becomes snappy about being touched, handled or approached, phone your vet before you treat it as a training problem — pain often shows up as a change in temperament first.
The breeds that genuinely suit families are the ones with a steady temperament, a size that fits your house, and an exercise need you can meet on a wet Tuesday in July. Looks are the worst predictor of all three.
The traits that matter in a house with children are narrow and specific. How does the dog handle being interrupted while it eats or sleeps. How does it take clumsy handling of its paws, ears and tail. And how quickly does it settle after a fright — a dropped pot, a scooter, a gate slamming.
A dog that startles and then goes back to sleep is far easier to live with than one that startles and stays wound up for an hour. Add biddability to that list: how much the dog wants to work with you rather than around you. Food-motivated dogs are usually the simplest to train, which matters when the person doing the training is eleven years old.
All of this varies more within a breed than between breeds. Meet the actual dog, and if it is a puppy, meet the mother and watch how she behaves with strangers in her own home.
Big dogs knock small children over without any intent to. Small dogs get hurt by small children, and a dog that has been hurt learns to defend itself. Neither is a temperament problem, and both are predictable from the moment you choose.
Then there is the lead. A dog you cannot physically hold is a dog that walks itself, and every adult and older child in the house should be able to hold it when a cat crosses the road. Weight also decides what the dog costs to feed, to board and to treat, because most of that scales with the animal.
Be honest about the property too. A large working dog on a townhouse patio is a problem no amount of good breeding fixes.
Herding and working breeds were built to work all day, and a garden is not exercise. A dog that does not get the work it was bred for will find its own: the gate, the washing line, the neighbour's dog, the couch. That is not naughtiness, it is an unemployed animal.
Count the walks that actually happen in winter when it is dark at six, not the ones you picture in December. If the honest answer is twenty minutes and a garden, choose a breed that is content with twenty minutes and a garden. There are plenty.
Heat matters here as well. Thick double coats and short flat faces both struggle through a Cape summer, and that limits when the dog can be walked at all.
Labradors and golden retrievers earn their reputation on temperament rather than looks. They are tolerant of handling, keen to please and easy to teach, though both need real daily exercise and both put on weight quickly without it.
Staffordshire bull terriers are strikingly people-oriented and patient with children in their own family. They are often far less patient with other dogs, so lead work and careful introductions are part of the deal. Poodles and poodle crosses are clever and shed less, but clever means bored fast, and the coat needs clipping on a schedule you keep. Beagles and other scent hounds are cheerful and sturdy, but the nose leads, so recall takes work and your fence has to be honest.
Some of the best family dogs are crossbreeds with no papers at all. An adult rescue whose temperament you can watch for an afternoon tells you more than any breed description of a puppy.
Huskies and other northern breeds are beautiful, built for cold, and need an amount of exercise most families cannot supply. Border collies and Malinois are brilliant and need a job; without one, a herding dog will herd your children. Jack Russells and small terriers are working dogs in a small body, not ornaments.
Boerboels and other guardian breeds are a separate decision. A well-bred one is devoted to its own family, but the size and the guarding instinct mean the first year of training decides what you live with for the next decade. It is not a first dog.
Many South African households want one animal to be both a family pet and a deterrent. Those two jobs pull in opposite directions — the dog that is suspicious of strangers is the dog that meets your child's friends at the gate. Decide which one you are actually buying.